Which, come to think of it, might not be so bad, either. A plate of Graham crackers served with a ice-cold glass of milk Credit: Getty Images - Getty How has the Graham cracker recipe changed? These cracker snacks really are incredibly easy to make. Apart from putting people off X … Combine for frosting: 1 1/2 – 2 cups powdered sugar (depending on how thick you want the frosting) 1/2 teaspoon almond extract (or vanilla, peppermint, lemon or any flavor you like) 2 Tablespoons milk. Apart from putting people off X-rated thoughts, Sylvester Graham's original recipe was created as an antidote to factory-made white bread. Graham Crackers With Frosting. Explore Bon Appétit Breakfast Graham Cracker … Stir and spread on graham crackers. Wait too long and you'll be left with very thick, graham cracker-flavored milk. A plate of Graham crackers served with a ice-cold glass of milk Credit: Getty Images - Getty How has the Graham cracker recipe changed? While Graham crackers don’t usually contain dairy products or eggs, honey pops up in many graham cracker products.